Republicans and Demo…
Republicans and Democrats have each presented their own government reform packages, but according to a watchdog group, neither is good enough.

Democrats on Wednesday declared an end to the “Republican culture of corruption,” announcing their own “real reform” plan one day after Republicans announced theirs.

House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi (Calif.) said the Democrat plan is about “real change and has real teeth.” It’s called the Honest Leadership and Open Government Act.

Democrat leaders said their “aggressive reform package” would “reverse Republican excesses and restore the public trust.”

But according to a taxpayer watchdog group, both parties have legitimate criticism to lob against each other’s reform proposals.

“The Republicans are right in saying that both parties have complicity in the current ethical mess, where campaign contributions and other gifts are given to Members of Congress in exchange for their support for government largesse for the contributors,” said John Berthoud, president of the National Taxpayers Union.

On the other hand, “The Democrats are right that the Republicans’ package doesn’t go nearly far enough,” Berthoud said.

“But the Democrats’ package is little better,” Berthoud said. “Their lackluster reform package gives lie to their claim that they are not part of the Washington problem.”

The problem is that both sides break the law, not that there aren’t enough laws. The reason they break the law is because there’s so much money floating around Washington because government is just way too big. Fortunately, there are those who are putting forth a real step in dealing with this root cause.

Lobbying reform alone is not enough, said the Council for Citizens Against Government Waste (CCAGW), which has urged Congress to fix the “mangled and secretive budget process.”

Tom Schatz, CCAGW president, said, “Bipartisan abuse of the budget process has led to record spending on pork barrel projects and handouts to special interests.”

According to CCAGW, total federal spending has swelled 67 percent, from $1.5 trillion in fiscal 1995 to almost $2.5 trillion in fiscal 2005. The number of pork-barrel projects in the federal budget during that same period of time has skyrocketed from 1,349 to 13,997, an increase of 938 percent.

CCAGW supports a bill introduced by Sen. John McCain and Rep. Jeff Flake, both Arizona Republicans. The bill, the Obligation of Funds Transparency Act (S. 1495 and H.R. 1642, respectively), would make earmarks more visible and amendable before legislation is passed.

Transparency with regard to the slinging around of pork is a good first step, and it’s just a first step. The more power and money we give to Washington, the more this kind of thing will happen, regardless of the number of “reforms” passed. Lobbying isn’t a crime and taking contributions from lobbyists isn’t a crime. However, the reason both of these legal actions can be abused is because in a government as large, complex and awash in money and power as ours, humanity’s weakness kicks in. Giving Washington more and more to do, especially those things that aren’t even constitutionally mandated, is simply an invitation for more abuse, and anyone who advocates for the former while ranting against the latter is ignorant at best and disingenuous at worst.

(Cross-posted at Stones Cry Out and Blogger News Network. Comments welcome.)

Filed under: Uncategorized

Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!