Same-Sex Marriage Update
California’s Proposition 8 would make "marriage" the union of one man and one woman. It amends the state constitution, since that was the battlefield chosen by liberal judges in that state’s Supreme Court when they made a decision earlier this year. James Taranto notes that what’s strange about this is that California already has a civil union laws that gives same-sex couples all the state-level legal benefits of marriage. Taranto links to a story about this in the Financial Times, and then wonders, if there’s no difference in the benefits…
So the rulings were only about the meaning of the term marriage. Why is this so important? We’ll let a prominent supporter of same-sex marriage, quoted by the FT, explain:
The advertising campaign backing the proposition, launched last month, features footage of San Francisco mayor Gavin Newsom speaking before supporters about gay marriage, saying "The door’s wide open now. It’s gonna happen, whether you like it or not."
The New York Times quotes from the Connecticut ruling:
"Although marriage and civil unions do embody the same legal rights under our law, they are by no means equal," Justice [Richard] Palmer wrote in the majority opinion, joined by Justices Flemming L. Norcott Jr., Joette Katz and Lubbie Harper. "The former is an institution of transcendent historical, cultural and social significance, whereas the latter is not."
The push for same-sex marriage, as distinct from civil unions, is not about tolerance or overcoming discrimination. It is about imposing a view of the "transcendent" on an unwilling public ("whether you like it or not"). If Proposition 8 passes, even supporters of same-sex marriage ought to take heart in a vote against this sort of arrogance.
This is further proof that, for the homosexual movement, "tolerance" and being left alone to do as they please is simply not enough, their words notwithstanding. It must include active acceptance and word redefinition. The main point of the FT article is the shock some gays have to how the polls seem to be going against them. Hopefully, the people of California are seeing who’s trying to force their will on them.
Filed under: Homosexuality • Marriage
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!
Leave a Reply